Opinion: Turkey and Russia aspire to replace a century of western domination of the Middle East

A "eurasianist" ideology is helping to consolidate a Russia - Turkey strategic alliance, as a viable tool to achieve long term strategic interests in the Middle East and beyond, says Benyamin Poghosyan in this op-ed

The security architecture of the Middle East is in the midst of a tremendous transformation. Since the end of the First World War the region has been under western domination of some form or other.  In 1920s and 1930s it was wrapped within the mandate system imposed by the League of Nation, and since the end of the Second World War the US has been the regional kingmaker. The Soviet Union had some footholds such as Egypt during Nasser's rule, as well as Syria and parts of Yemen. However, it was never in a position to contain the US. The US influence peaked after the end of the Cold War, and probably the most vivid example of the US decisive role was the 2003 American incursion into Iraq. However, the regional turmoil caused by the Arab Spring, the withdrawal of the bulk of American forces from the Iraq, the growing influence of Iran, as well as Russia's military intervention in the Syrian conflict have effectively ended US hegemony in the Middle East.

One of the key factors shaping the geopolitical developments in the region is the growing Russia - Turkish partnership in parallel with the unraveling of Ankara - Washington relations. Since joining NATO Turkey has been one of the key US allies in the region, and the regional bulwark against the Soviet Union. However, the collapse of the Soviet Union eliminated the key rationale behind the US - Turkey strategic alliance.   Both sides were on an urgent quest to find a new basis for the relations - Turkey as a channel for the US influence in the newly independent Muslim republics of Central Asia, and more recently Turkey as a model of moderate Islamic power successfully combining Islam and Democracy. However, none of these concepts have fully materialized. The divergent interests in the Syrian conflict, especially on the Kurdish role, as well as Turkish suspicions on the US position regarding the 2016 July failed military coup, have brought the bilateral relationship to the brink of collapse.

Russia - Turkish relations hit the bottom in November 2015 after the downing of a Russian military jet. However, both sides were able to renew bilateral cooperation just eight month after the crisis. Since the pivotal meeting of the two presidents in Saint Petersburg in August 2016 the relations have warmed up significantly. The start of the Turkish stream pipeline construction, finalization of negotiations on the Akkuyu nuclear power plant, the agreement to purchase Russian S - 400 air defense systems, the launch of the Astana process and the establishment of de-escalation zones in Syria in close cooperation with Iran, the convening of the Syrian National Dialogue Congress in Sochi, are all vivid examples of growing bilateral partnership.

The tacit Russian consent for the Turkish military operation currently underway in Syrian Afrin, as well as the unprecedented frequency of high level contacts including, almost monthly phone talks between President Putin and Erdogan, point to the high level of confidence between the two partners. The March 13-14 visit of Turkish Minister of Foreign Affairs Mevlut Chavushoglu to Moscow, as well as the decision regarding President Putin's upcoming visit to Turkey in early April, are also indicators of growing cooperation. 

The emerging Russia - Turkish partnership also has a solid ideological background. It relies on the idea of Eurasianism, fiercely promoted in Russia by the leader of the "International Eurasian Movement" Professor Aleksandr Dugin. The author of several books on Geopolitics, Dugin puts forward the idea to establish Russian - Turkish alliance to counter the United States. According to Dugin, Turkey is one of the key actors in "Rimland", and both Russia as a "Heartland" and the US as a "Sea Power" are struggling to pull Turkey into their orbit to secure their dominance over the Eurasia. Dugin's theory emphasizes the significance of trilateral Russia - Turkey - Iran geostrategic cooperation, which may unite Turkey as a leader of Sunnis, Iran as a leader of Shias and Russia as a leader of Orthodox Christians in their struggle against the West. Thus, the growing Russia - Turkey - Iran cooperation in Syria is fully in line with Dugin's concepts.

Dugin has established close ties with different Turkish intellectual and political circles including the chairman of the "Patriotic" party Doghu Perincheq, which itself is pro eurasianist and one of the close supporters of President Erdogan. In 2016 - 2017 Dugin visited Turkey many times and had some high profile meetings including discussions with Turkish Prime Minister Binali Yildirim. Despite the fact that Dugin was forced out from Moscow State University in 2014 due to his radical stance during the Ukraine crisis, he is widely believed to yield some influence on President Putin's inner circle, and his monographs on geopolitics are among mandatory readings in the military academies of the Russian General Staff.

Given the growing gap between the US and Turkey, many in the Turkish political and military elites perceive Eurasian ideology, and the establishment of a Russia - Turkey strategic alliance, as a viable tool to secure Turkey's long term strategic interests in the Middle East and beyond. If it materializes, this scenario may fundamentally alter the balance of power in the Middle East putting the US  on the defensive, and effectively ending almost a century of western domination in the region. 

Dr. Benyamin Poghosyan is the Executive Director of the Political Science Association of Armenia. He contributed this op-ed to commonspace.eu

 

Related articles

Editor's choice
News
Borrell tells the European Parliament that the situation in Afghanistan was critical, but the EU will remain engaged

Borrell tells the European Parliament that the situation in Afghanistan was critical, but the EU will remain engaged

Borrell underlined that the European Union will make every effort to support the peace process and to remain a committed partner to the Afghan people. "Of course, we will have to take into account the evolving situation, but disengagement is not an option.  We are clear on that: there is no alternative to a negotiated political settlement, through inclusive peace talks.
Editor's choice
News
Dozens participate in new Armenia-Azerbaijan dialogue process as societies prepare for the signing of historic peace agreement

Dozens participate in new Armenia-Azerbaijan dialogue process as societies prepare for the signing of historic peace agreement

The governments of Armenia and Azerbaijan have recently agreed the text of a historic peace agreement that ends years of animosity and warfare. The agreement is expected to be signed soon. LINKS Europe, which has a long history of engagement with the process of peace in the region, recently launched a new Armenia-Azerbaijan dialogue format in the framework of the European Union's EU4Peace initiative. In the last two weeks dozens of Armenians and Azerbaijanis, including academics, students, civil society activists, journalists and other professionals, many of them young, were involved. The work is organised in five thematic groups focusing on peace and security, connectivity, environment, governance and gender and equality and in phase 2 of the project, which has just ended, around fifty participants took part in in-person and online meetings, and more than twenty others were involved indirectly. The Chairpersons of the five thematic groups met in Vilnius, 3-6 July to launch the third phase of the program. The five thematic groups are now working on separate reports, which are expected to be finished in November and presented to the two governments and other stakeholders. The reports will outline a vision, up to 2040.

Popular

Editor's choice
News
Dozens participate in new Armenia-Azerbaijan dialogue process as societies prepare for the signing of historic peace agreement

Dozens participate in new Armenia-Azerbaijan dialogue process as societies prepare for the signing of historic peace agreement

The governments of Armenia and Azerbaijan have recently agreed the text of a historic peace agreement that ends years of animosity and warfare. The agreement is expected to be signed soon. LINKS Europe, which has a long history of engagement with the process of peace in the region, recently launched a new Armenia-Azerbaijan dialogue format in the framework of the European Union's EU4Peace initiative. In the last two weeks dozens of Armenians and Azerbaijanis, including academics, students, civil society activists, journalists and other professionals, many of them young, were involved. The work is organised in five thematic groups focusing on peace and security, connectivity, environment, governance and gender and equality and in phase 2 of the project, which has just ended, around fifty participants took part in in-person and online meetings, and more than twenty others were involved indirectly. The Chairpersons of the five thematic groups met in Vilnius, 3-6 July to launch the third phase of the program. The five thematic groups are now working on separate reports, which are expected to be finished in November and presented to the two governments and other stakeholders. The reports will outline a vision, up to 2040.