OPINION: Dennis Sammut "The people of the South Caucasus need to rethink the relationship between them, beyond the constraints of the present situation".

The way the Caucasus Region is seen by the outside world has changed dramatically over the last decade.

For much of the Soviet period the region was perceived as being militarily sensitive. Large areas were closed to visitors completely, whilst travel by foreigners to other parts was usually limited to organised tours through the state tourism company Intourist. The world’s view of the Caucasus was therefore of an exotic, somewhat wild place, and there was very little understanding of the people, the region and its problems.

News about the inter-ethnic conflicts of the late 1980s and early 1990s got very little coverage in the western media, which was much more concerned with the goings on in Moscow rather than the bloody, but in the greater scheme of things less important, events in one of the USSRs peripheries.

Things did not change very much after the dissolution of the USSR and independence. The Americans and the Germans moved quickly to open embassies in Baku, Yerevan and Tbilisi but they were generally empty shells, staffed by a few diplomats and without a budget except for essentials. The British, the Dutch and the Scandinavians arrived much later. The Russians took a long time rethinking their post imperial role in the region – and some say they have not yet finished the process.

To their credit the governments and people of Armenia, Azerbaijan and Georgia pushed on with their state-building projects and proved wrong the sceptics, who had wondered how long these new states will exist. The tools that the three countries had were few and far between but they used them well and imaginatively:  the Armenians used the diaspora, the Azerbaijanis the leverage of their natural resources, and the Georgians, having neither of these, led by their two larger than life presidents of the last twenty years, Shevardnadze and Saakashvili, used their creativity.

As the three countries celebrated their two decades of independence last year, they rightly all had some reason to be satisfied. not least because of their improved standing in the world

Streams of delegations now pour into the three capitals for bilateral and multilateral discussions. The three countries are members of all major international organisations, they are negotiating association agreements with the European Union, are members of NATOs partnership for Peace, and Azerbaijan is this year even a member of the United Nations Security Council. The impression of the world is that the three countries have steadied and are (most of the time) reliable partners, despite the fact that they can sometimes be awkward.

Here however the good news stops. Despite its progress the region is still seen as a potential trouble spot and a lot of the outside focus is more concerned with containing problems rather than solving them. The problems of the past plague the present and cast a  cloud over the future. In the three countries the political divide between government and opposition is deep and the process of building democratic institutions is far from complete. Corruption remains an issue even in Georgia where much of the petty corruption has been eliminated. Boundaries remain disputed. Three unrecognised entities, two under the protection of Russia and one under the protection of Armenia now claim their space south of the Caucasus Mountains.

This situation has hampered development and has often created problems between the region and the outside world. The region is far from being able to achieve its full potential, politically, economically, culturally as well as in many other fields.

The governments of the region need to start focusing on the big, long term picture, but that is not going to happen on its own.

The outside world can help nudge it along but first and foremost there must be more grass root demands for a radical strategic rethinking of inter-regional relations. 

Unfortunately a lot of post-independence pan-Caucasian schemes at the non-governmental level seem to have run out of steam, and those that haven’t lack the imagination that is required to think beyond the present constraints. Very few people with the necessary vision and independence of thinking seem to engage with these processes any more

Twenty years after independence it is time for Armenians Azerbaijanis and Georgians, and indeed for Abkhaz and Ossetians and other nationalities in the region, to think beyond the constraints of the present situation and to start articulating ideas that can eventually be picked up by governments and politicians so that in twenty years’ time the world can look at the South Caucasus and see a prosperous and dynamic region at peace with itself and with its neighbours.

Dennis Sammut contributed this opinion to Commonspace.eu. He can be contacted at dennissammut@yahoo.co.uk

Related articles

Editor's choice
News
Borrell tells the European Parliament that the situation in Afghanistan was critical, but the EU will remain engaged

Borrell tells the European Parliament that the situation in Afghanistan was critical, but the EU will remain engaged

Borrell underlined that the European Union will make every effort to support the peace process and to remain a committed partner to the Afghan people. "Of course, we will have to take into account the evolving situation, but disengagement is not an option.  We are clear on that: there is no alternative to a negotiated political settlement, through inclusive peace talks.
Editor's choice
News
Dozens participate in new Armenia-Azerbaijan dialogue process as societies prepare for the signing of historic peace agreement

Dozens participate in new Armenia-Azerbaijan dialogue process as societies prepare for the signing of historic peace agreement

The governments of Armenia and Azerbaijan have recently agreed the text of a historic peace agreement that ends years of animosity and warfare. The agreement is expected to be signed soon. LINKS Europe, which has a long history of engagement with the process of peace in the region, recently launched a new Armenia-Azerbaijan dialogue format in the framework of the European Union's EU4Peace initiative. In the last two weeks dozens of Armenians and Azerbaijanis, including academics, students, civil society activists, journalists and other professionals, many of them young, were involved. The work is organised in five thematic groups focusing on peace and security, connectivity, environment, governance and gender and equality and in phase 2 of the project, which has just ended, around fifty participants took part in in-person and online meetings, and more than twenty others were involved indirectly. The Chairpersons of the five thematic groups met in Vilnius, 3-6 July to launch the third phase of the program. The five thematic groups are now working on separate reports, which are expected to be finished in November and presented to the two governments and other stakeholders. The reports will outline a vision, up to 2040.

Popular

Editor's choice
News
Dozens participate in new Armenia-Azerbaijan dialogue process as societies prepare for the signing of historic peace agreement

Dozens participate in new Armenia-Azerbaijan dialogue process as societies prepare for the signing of historic peace agreement

The governments of Armenia and Azerbaijan have recently agreed the text of a historic peace agreement that ends years of animosity and warfare. The agreement is expected to be signed soon. LINKS Europe, which has a long history of engagement with the process of peace in the region, recently launched a new Armenia-Azerbaijan dialogue format in the framework of the European Union's EU4Peace initiative. In the last two weeks dozens of Armenians and Azerbaijanis, including academics, students, civil society activists, journalists and other professionals, many of them young, were involved. The work is organised in five thematic groups focusing on peace and security, connectivity, environment, governance and gender and equality and in phase 2 of the project, which has just ended, around fifty participants took part in in-person and online meetings, and more than twenty others were involved indirectly. The Chairpersons of the five thematic groups met in Vilnius, 3-6 July to launch the third phase of the program. The five thematic groups are now working on separate reports, which are expected to be finished in November and presented to the two governments and other stakeholders. The reports will outline a vision, up to 2040.