Trending
Shenzhen is not Yalta
18 November 2026
This is a comment prepared by the editorial team of commonspace.eu
The leaders of Russia, China and the United States will meet on Thursday, 19 November 2026, in the city of Shenzhen, on the margins of the APEC summit, taking place in the Chinese city. Some are calling the summit historic, and the leaders of the three countries have never met in this format before. They call themselves the G3, and are being compared with the meeting of Roosevelt, Churchill and Stalin in 1945 in Yalta. But this is no Yalta 2.0, and the world does not have to hold it breath, and await the outcome. Yet the meeting is not without importance, and the messages that it sends are not without significance.
As London’s Financial Times put it, “While expected to deliver few concrete outcomes, the powerful imagery of Trump meeting authoritarian Xi and revanchist Putin will reverberate throughout the world, especially in flashpoints such as Ukraine, Taiwan, and the Middle East”. Let us be clear, this is first and foremost a photo opportunity. The Russian and the American leaders need this. China less so, and at first were quite reluctant. In the end they saw something in it for them, and they acquiesced.
For the US the main topic is arms control, and particularly how to bring China in the frame of a new arms control agreement; for Putin it is Ukraine. The Chinese are not ready to discuss either very deeply, and will instead focus on “global stability”.
For Putin the summit is a win. It brings Russia back to the front. But the reality is that it is increasingly dependant on China, and Trump cannot deliver the kind of agreement on Ukraine that Russia wants. The G3 will not discuss Ukraine.
The Chinese see the summit as another proof that they are now a superpower. They are happy to sustain the current trade truce with the US, whilst taking a long term view and using the interim period to strengthen their economic and military strength.
Trump goes to the summit damaged. The war in Iran has done nothing but harm to the US. From January, Congress will be controlled by the Democrats. He is still the president, and still Commander in Chief, but he is much weakened.
Its unlikely that anything positive will come out from the G3 summit. But it is good that the three are talking, and it is good that they will agree, as is likely, to talk more.