PACE resolution on Karabakh triggers controversy.

A draft resolution on Nagorno-Karabakh, adopted by the Political Committee of the Parliamentary Assembly of the Council of Europe (PACE) on  5 November has triggered controversy within the region, and in the international community. The resolution, based on a report prepared by British Conservative MP, Robert Walter, will in January be discussed in a full plenary  of PACE in Strasbourg, but it has already created much debate.

As reported by commonspace.eu last week (read here) the resolution has departed from the usual language that has characterised international statements on Nagorno-Karabakh. As was expected the resolution was welcomed in Azerbaijan, where the government has been insisting for a long time for tougher language in the context of Armenian occupation of its territory, but has been derided in Armenia where the issue is seen to be one of self-determination and liberation. A spokesperson for the Armenian Foreign Ministry immediately dismissed the report, and said that PACE had no mandate to work on the Karabakh issue.

Armenia has for a long time insisted that the only format for negotiations on Nagorno-Karabakh is the OSCE Minsk Process. In recent years however this position has developed into a much more restrictive stance, whereby Armenia insists that no other international organisation has a right to speak about the Nagorno-Karabakh issue outside the parameters of the OSCE Minsk Group co-Chair statements.

The position was echoed in Karabakh itself. A spokesperson for the Foreign Ministry of the self- declared Nagorno-Karabakh Republic, Ani Sargsyan told "Artsakhpress" news agency, "We consider unacceptable the approach of the PACE Rapporteur, who took as a basis the position of only one party to the conflict in the preparation of the report and, instead of giving an unbiased and neutral assessment of the situation, set forth all the propaganda theses of the Azerbaijani side in the report".

Both Armenia and the de facto authorities in Stepanakert refused to engage with Robert Walter as he was preparing the report, again insisting that PACE had no mandate to interfere in the matter

Unexpectedly, the US Co-Chair of the OSCE Minsk Process, Ambassador James Warlick jumped into the fray on Friday, tweeting "PACE and other intl orgs should consult with the @OSCE Co-chairs before issuing reports or resolutions on Nagorno-#Karabakh".  Not surprisingly within hours of his tweet Warlick was lambasted in a statement by the spokesperson of  the Azerbaijani Foreign Ministry, Hikmat Hajiev. "What the OSCE Minsk Group co-chairs have done so far is close to zero so there is no need for other organizations that are trying to help settle the conflict to consult with the OSCE Minsk Group co-chairs," Hajiyev said. "Such ineffective activity of the OSCE Minsk Group is in the interests of Armenia, continuing the aggressive policy and striving to maintain the status quo," Hajiyev said. The Azerbaijani news agency APA reported that Hajiyev further said  "that it is not excluded that Warlick is an integral element of the plan that is serving the continuation of the aggressive policy of Armenia".

Source: commonspace.eu with agencies

Image: The boundary line between Armenia and the self-declared Nagorno-Karabakh Republic (Picture courtesy of Roberto Travan, La Stampa, Italy).

 

 

Related articles

Editor's choice
News
Borrell tells the European Parliament that the situation in Afghanistan was critical, but the EU will remain engaged

Borrell tells the European Parliament that the situation in Afghanistan was critical, but the EU will remain engaged

Borrell underlined that the European Union will make every effort to support the peace process and to remain a committed partner to the Afghan people. "Of course, we will have to take into account the evolving situation, but disengagement is not an option.  We are clear on that: there is no alternative to a negotiated political settlement, through inclusive peace talks.
Editor's choice
News
Thirty Armenian members of the five Armenian-Azerbaijani Thematic Groups meet in Yerevan

Thirty Armenian members of the five Armenian-Azerbaijani Thematic Groups meet in Yerevan

Yesterday (23 September) around thirty Armenians involved in the five Armenian-Azerbaijani Thematic Groups gathered in Yerevan to be briefed by Leonid Narsisian, co-Chair of the thematic group on Peace and Security; Narek Minasyan, Chair of the thematic group on regional connectivity; Sargis Harutyunyan, Chair of the thematic group on Governance; Aghavni Harutyunyan, Deputy Chair of the thematic group on Environment; and Andranik Shirinyan, Deputy Chair of the thematic group on gender and diversity. The Thematic Groups are a LINKS Europe initiative aimed at promoting a new style of Armenia-Azerbaijan dialogue, fit for the new reality. They will present their five reports in mid-November. We were delighted to welcome to the meeting in Yerevan, Murad Muradov, Azerbaijani co-Chair of the thematic group on peace and security who also spoke. Others to address the meeting included Erik Jessen, Political Officer at the EU Delegation in Armenia, Stepan Grigoryan, Senior Member of the Armenia-Azerbaijan Expert Strategic Platform (under the auspices of LINKS Europe), and Dennis Sammut, Director and George Simonishvili, South Caucasus coordinator, of LINKS Europe. It was a very good and engaging meeting, also attended by representatives of various embassies, including HE Marieke Monroy-Winter, the Ambassador of The Netherlands. A similar meeting with Azerbaijani members will take place in Baku on Friday (26 September). The Armenian and Azerbaijani members have been meeting on line since April. On 27 October they will meet together in Tbilisi to finalise their work.

Popular

Editor's choice
News
Thirty Armenian members of the five Armenian-Azerbaijani Thematic Groups meet in Yerevan

Thirty Armenian members of the five Armenian-Azerbaijani Thematic Groups meet in Yerevan

Yesterday (23 September) around thirty Armenians involved in the five Armenian-Azerbaijani Thematic Groups gathered in Yerevan to be briefed by Leonid Narsisian, co-Chair of the thematic group on Peace and Security; Narek Minasyan, Chair of the thematic group on regional connectivity; Sargis Harutyunyan, Chair of the thematic group on Governance; Aghavni Harutyunyan, Deputy Chair of the thematic group on Environment; and Andranik Shirinyan, Deputy Chair of the thematic group on gender and diversity. The Thematic Groups are a LINKS Europe initiative aimed at promoting a new style of Armenia-Azerbaijan dialogue, fit for the new reality. They will present their five reports in mid-November. We were delighted to welcome to the meeting in Yerevan, Murad Muradov, Azerbaijani co-Chair of the thematic group on peace and security who also spoke. Others to address the meeting included Erik Jessen, Political Officer at the EU Delegation in Armenia, Stepan Grigoryan, Senior Member of the Armenia-Azerbaijan Expert Strategic Platform (under the auspices of LINKS Europe), and Dennis Sammut, Director and George Simonishvili, South Caucasus coordinator, of LINKS Europe. It was a very good and engaging meeting, also attended by representatives of various embassies, including HE Marieke Monroy-Winter, the Ambassador of The Netherlands. A similar meeting with Azerbaijani members will take place in Baku on Friday (26 September). The Armenian and Azerbaijani members have been meeting on line since April. On 27 October they will meet together in Tbilisi to finalise their work.