Menu
Latest
Menu
Latest
Power Struggle in Tbilisi. Joseph Alexander Smith reports on political drama that has shaken the ruling coalition in Georgia.

Power Struggle in Tbilisi. Joseph Alexander Smith reports on political drama that has shaken the ruling coalition in Georgia.

7 November 2014

Joseph Alexander Smith reports from Tbilisi for commonspace.eu on forty-eight hours of political drama that has shaken the ruling coalition in Georgia.

Georgia is in the midst of an ongoing political crisis after the dismissal of the Minister of Defence, the subsequent resignation of two key ministers and a split within the ruling coalition. The unexpected turn of events has left Georgia's EU and NATO partners questioning whether the country's government is still committed to a pro-Western foreign policy course.

The crisis was sparked on Tuesday night when the Prime Minister, Irakli Gharibashvili, announced the dismissal of Iraklia Alasania, Georgia's Minister of Defence since October 2012. One former and four serving officials in Alasania's ministry had been arrested in relation to an allegedly corrupt tender. Alasania, who was in Germany at the time, protested the detentions, shortly before new charges were filed against several army medical staff.

Alasania denounced the charges as "obviously politically motivated" and "an attack on Georgia's Euro-Atlantic choice." The Prime Minister responded by labelling the Defence Minister's remarks "irresponsible" and promptly sacking him.

The dismissal of the Defence Minister, was shortly followed by the resignation of Alexi Petriashvili, the State Minister for Euro-Atlantic Integration and a fellow member of Alasania's Free Democrats party. The following day, Minister of Foreign Affairs Maia Panjikidze (who is also Alasania's sister-in-law), announced her resignation along with some of her deputies. Justice Minister Tea Tsulukiani, who is affiliated with the Free Democrats and whose departure was also expected, has announced that she will remain in her post.

All deputies in the Defence Ministry were dismissed and Alasania's portfolio was handed to Mindia Janelidze, a little known figure who has previously served as security advisor to the PM and head of counter-intelligence during Gharibashvili's tenure as Interior Minister.
After a political council on Wednesday, the Free Democrats announced that they would withdraw from the ruling six-party Georgian Dream (GD) coalition which came to power 2 years ago under the leadership of billionaire businessman Bidzina Ivanishvili. The departure of all ten Free Democrat MPs would leave the coalition three seats short of a clear majority in the 150 seat parliament, but it remains to be seen whether all members will leave the majority bloc.

Although the Prime Minister has emphatically re-iterated his government's commitment to a pro-Western foreign policy course, the loss of three ministers central to the process of Euro-Atlantic integration has left many of Georgia's foreign partners alarmed.

Alasania himself is a well-known figure abroad, having served as Georgia's UN Ambassador during the 2008 war with Russia. According to a recent opinion poll conducted by the National Democratic Institute, Alasania is also Georgia's most popular politician.

Former Swedish Foreign Minister Carl Bildt tweeted about the "Grave political crisis in Georgia. Attacks on and sacking of DefMin Alasania. Path of the country under threat." Speaking of "legitimate concern that the judicial system is being used in a politicized way", US Ambassador to Georgia, Richard Norland, commented that "at a time of regional turmoil and domestic economic challenge what Georgia needs the most is stability, unity, demonstrated commitment to due process and the rule of law, and public confidence in democratic institutions." However, NATO's Caucasus envoy, James Appathurai, was more guarded in his comments, acknowledging the Prime Minister's "clear statement that these developments will not divert Georgia from its Euro-Atlantic path" which he believes "reflects the will of the Georgian people."

In comments made on Georgian TV shortly after his dismissal, Alasania made an explicit link between his sacking and Georgia's foreign policy choice. He also, alluded to President Giorgi Margvelashvili's recent comments that Georgia should be ruled by "strong institutions, not from backstage", implying that the order came from GD founder Bidzina Ivanshvili, whom many believe still exerts a strong influence on Prime Minister Gharibashvili.

Alasania has also suggested that his dismissal serves Russian interests, represented by ‘groups' within the government that he refused to name when pressed. While the accuracy of Alasania's account remains to be proven, political instability and the chance of early parliamentary elections, current scheduled for 2016, could open up space in the political arena for more conservative opposition parties which are skeptical of Georgia's EU and NATO ambitions and open to closer relations with Russia.

source: Joseph Alexander Smith reporting from Tbilisi for commonspace.eu

photo: Irakli Alasania and Irakli Gharibashvili reviewing military exercises of Georgia's special forces in November 2013. (photo courtesy of civil.ge)

Related articles

Editor's choice
News
Borrell tells the European Parliament that the situation in Afghanistan was critical, but the EU will remain engaged
Trending

Borrell tells the European Parliament that the situation in Afghanistan was critical, but the EU will remain engaged

9 June 2021
Borrell underlined that the European Union will make every effort to support the peace process and to remain a committed partner to the Afghan people. "Of course, we will have to take into account the evolving situation, but disengagement is not an option.  We are clear on that: there is no alternative to a negotiated political settlement, through inclusive peace talks.
Editor's choice
News
Bonn Dialogue Meeting calls for the theme "Climate Change, Peace and Security" to be included in the agenda of COP29
Trending

Bonn Dialogue Meeting calls for the theme "Climate Change, Peace and Security" to be included in the agenda of COP29

6 May 2024
A dialogue meeting on the topic: “Climate Change Peace and Security – COP 29 and Beyond” was held at the Bonn University Club in Bonn, Germany, on Friday, 3 May 2024. Representatives of various state-parties to the Climate Convention and of the UN Climate Secretariat, joined participants from around 30 academic institutions, think tanks and civil society organisations to review the work done on this topic at COP28 in Dubai in December and chart a way forward for ensuring the continuation of the process at the COP29 meeting in Baku in November. At the opening session, the meeting was addressed by HE Hana al Hashemi, the United Arab Emirates COP28 Chief negotiator, HE Nigar Arpadarai, the UN High-Level Champion for COP29 in Azerbaijan, and Mr Markus Hicken, Director for Energy Foreign Policy, Climate and Security at the German Federal Foreign Office. Also speaking at the opening session was Ms Maria Paloma Noriega Jalil, representing the UN Climate Secretariat. There followed an intensive one-day of discussions on the current state of the COP process, and the on-going debate on the nexus of Climate Change, Peace and Security within the COP process. The meeting was addressed by world-class experts from leading think tanks and academic institutions, including Chatham House, the German Council on Foreign Relations, ADELPHI, the School of Oriental and African Studies in London, Heidelberg University, The Hertie School in Berlin, amongst others. The meeting positively assessed the steps taken in COP28 in Dubai in December, including the inclusion of climate change, peace and security as a theme of the meeting, the holding for the first time of a day on peace in the deliberations, and the “COP28 Declaration on Climate, Relief, Recovery and Peace”. It was felt that it was important that this momentum will not be lost, and similar actions are also included as part of the COP29 meeting in Baku in November. Whilst it was recognised that the nexus between Climate Change Peace and Security was now widely recognised internationally, inserting this in the COP process remained an issue under discussion. During the meeting three aspects of the Climate Change, Peace and Security agenda were highlighted, namely water scarcity; food insecurity; and landmine contamination and environmental degradation resulting from conflict. Participants called on the State Parties to the Climate Convention meeting in the context of COP29 to ensure proper discussion and action on these themes that affect millions of people and thousands of communities across the world. In his concluding remarks at the end of the dialogue meeting, HE Ambassador Elshad Iskanderov, advisor to the COP 29 presidency, said that Azerbaijan was positive to the idea of having Climate Change Peace and Security as a theme at COP29. Ambassador Iskanderov reminded that the decision to hold COP29 in Baku was taken unanimously, and was an unprecedented confidence-building measure in the context of the South Caucasus.  Azerbaijan wanted to build on what had already been achieved in Dubai. He said that these decisions did not depend on Azerbaijan alone since COP was a multilateral process where the 198 state parties had the final say. Ambassador Iskanderov underlined the readiness of the Azerbaijani COP29 presidency to continue the dialogue on this issue with academia, think tanks and civil society as the preparations for COP 29 progress. He highlighted the fact that the discussion needs to focus not only on the potential that climate change will fuel more conflict and insecurity, but also on the impact of conflicts on climate change and environmental degradation Concluding the Bonn Dialogue Meeting, Dr Dennis Sammut, Director of LINKS Europe Foundation, who together with Candid Foundation and ReStart Initiative hosted the Bonn event, said that a lot of work needs to be done between now and November, and particularly the dialogue with the COP Troika countries, the UN Climate Secretariat and interested state parties needs to be continued and intensified. As a concrete step, LINKS Europe will set up an ad hoc working group with other interested non-state actors, to ensure that the conversation continues, and tangible results are achieved.

Popular

Editor's choice
News
Bonn Dialogue Meeting calls for the theme "Climate Change, Peace and Security" to be included in the agenda of COP29
Trending

Bonn Dialogue Meeting calls for the theme "Climate Change, Peace and Security" to be included in the agenda of COP29

6 May 2024
A dialogue meeting on the topic: “Climate Change Peace and Security – COP 29 and Beyond” was held at the Bonn University Club in Bonn, Germany, on Friday, 3 May 2024. Representatives of various state-parties to the Climate Convention and of the UN Climate Secretariat, joined participants from around 30 academic institutions, think tanks and civil society organisations to review the work done on this topic at COP28 in Dubai in December and chart a way forward for ensuring the continuation of the process at the COP29 meeting in Baku in November. At the opening session, the meeting was addressed by HE Hana al Hashemi, the United Arab Emirates COP28 Chief negotiator, HE Nigar Arpadarai, the UN High-Level Champion for COP29 in Azerbaijan, and Mr Markus Hicken, Director for Energy Foreign Policy, Climate and Security at the German Federal Foreign Office. Also speaking at the opening session was Ms Maria Paloma Noriega Jalil, representing the UN Climate Secretariat. There followed an intensive one-day of discussions on the current state of the COP process, and the on-going debate on the nexus of Climate Change, Peace and Security within the COP process. The meeting was addressed by world-class experts from leading think tanks and academic institutions, including Chatham House, the German Council on Foreign Relations, ADELPHI, the School of Oriental and African Studies in London, Heidelberg University, The Hertie School in Berlin, amongst others. The meeting positively assessed the steps taken in COP28 in Dubai in December, including the inclusion of climate change, peace and security as a theme of the meeting, the holding for the first time of a day on peace in the deliberations, and the “COP28 Declaration on Climate, Relief, Recovery and Peace”. It was felt that it was important that this momentum will not be lost, and similar actions are also included as part of the COP29 meeting in Baku in November. Whilst it was recognised that the nexus between Climate Change Peace and Security was now widely recognised internationally, inserting this in the COP process remained an issue under discussion. During the meeting three aspects of the Climate Change, Peace and Security agenda were highlighted, namely water scarcity; food insecurity; and landmine contamination and environmental degradation resulting from conflict. Participants called on the State Parties to the Climate Convention meeting in the context of COP29 to ensure proper discussion and action on these themes that affect millions of people and thousands of communities across the world. In his concluding remarks at the end of the dialogue meeting, HE Ambassador Elshad Iskanderov, advisor to the COP 29 presidency, said that Azerbaijan was positive to the idea of having Climate Change Peace and Security as a theme at COP29. Ambassador Iskanderov reminded that the decision to hold COP29 in Baku was taken unanimously, and was an unprecedented confidence-building measure in the context of the South Caucasus.  Azerbaijan wanted to build on what had already been achieved in Dubai. He said that these decisions did not depend on Azerbaijan alone since COP was a multilateral process where the 198 state parties had the final say. Ambassador Iskanderov underlined the readiness of the Azerbaijani COP29 presidency to continue the dialogue on this issue with academia, think tanks and civil society as the preparations for COP 29 progress. He highlighted the fact that the discussion needs to focus not only on the potential that climate change will fuel more conflict and insecurity, but also on the impact of conflicts on climate change and environmental degradation Concluding the Bonn Dialogue Meeting, Dr Dennis Sammut, Director of LINKS Europe Foundation, who together with Candid Foundation and ReStart Initiative hosted the Bonn event, said that a lot of work needs to be done between now and November, and particularly the dialogue with the COP Troika countries, the UN Climate Secretariat and interested state parties needs to be continued and intensified. As a concrete step, LINKS Europe will set up an ad hoc working group with other interested non-state actors, to ensure that the conversation continues, and tangible results are achieved.