Opinion: Yeraskh metallurgical plant becomes the latest dispute threatening to complicate the Armenia-Azerbaijan peace process

“Disputes like the one surrounding the Yeraskh metallurgical plant pose a genuine risk to the realisation of a durable peace between Armenia and Azerbaijan. Indeed, as the Espoo Convention notes, environmental issues do not respect borders and specific cases should be discussed on an international level when multiple state-parties are concerned,” writes Patrick Norén for commonspace.eu. “But in order for Armenia and Azerbaijan to move forward together in an era of peace, there must also be an understanding that one country’s domestic development can also be to the benefit of the other country. Zero-sum calculations of such issues are unhelpful and distract from the fact that Armenia and Azerbaijan can all be winners if they do cooperate, whether it be on the environment, on trade, or on any other sector.”

On 3 June, the Armenian Minister of Economy Vahan Kerobyan posted a video on his Facebook page announcing the construction of a new metallurgical plant in the Armenian town of Yeraskh, located less than a kilometre north of the Armenian border with Azerbaijan’s Nakhchivan province. 

The plant would be built by the American-Armenian company GTB Steel, with an investment of $70 million. Kerobyan added that the plant would be some 30m high, have an area of 16,500 square metres, and would produce up to 180,000 tonnes of steel annually. While 200 people currently work there, the completed steel smelting plant would employ up to 1,000 people.

Azerbaijan fears "serious negative impact" on their ecological environment from Yeraskh plant

This announcement quickly attracted criticism from the Azerbaijani Ministry of Ecology and Natural Resources, who in a statement released on 7 June described the planned metallurgical plant right on their border as a gross violation of international law, especially international environmental law. 

Citing the United Nations’ Espoo Convention, under which governments must notify and consult each other on all major projects under consideration that might have an adverse environmental impact across borders, Azerbaijan said that Armenia “should have ensured the participation of Azerbaijan and the public in the affected areas in the transboundary environmental impact assessment procedure before starting the said activity”.

Furthermore, in their statement on the Yeraskh metallurgical plant, the Azerbaijani Ministry of Ecology and Natural Resources accused the Armenian mining industry of having a “serious negative impact on the ecological environment of Azerbaijan”, citing the Kajaran copper-molybdenum plant and the Kapan ore processing plant as having been “intensively polluting” the transboundary Voghji/Okchuchay river.

“We strongly condemn the actions of Armenia, which harm the ecological security of the region and are contrary to the norms of international law, and we call on the international community to pay special attention to this issue,” the Azerbaijani statement concluded.

GTB Steel and Armenian Ministry of the Environment counter Azerbaijan's criticism of the Yeraskh metallurgical plant

The dispute escalated further on 8 June when GTB Steel issued a strong statement countering Azerbaijan’s criticism of the planned smelting plant. GTB Steel said that they had received a positive response in an Environmental Impact Assessment from Armenia’s Ministry of the Environment, adding that “all modern technologies for the exclusion of negative impact on the environment will be implemented and all equivalent measures will be carried out”.

GTB Steel said they would continue their activities in Yeraskh because it would be of benefit to border communities and Armenia as a whole, suggesting that precisely this fact might explain “the reaction of the neighbouring state”.

The Armenian Ministry of the Environment doubled down on GTB Steel’s criticism of Azerbaijan in a statement released on 9 June, insisting that the plant would be “constructed in accordance with the environmental standards and requirements, within the framework of domestic legal regulations”, while also accusing Azerbaijan of deliberately using “environmental false alarms” to try to hinder Armenia’s economic development.

The war of words did not stop there. On Tuesday (13 June), Azerbaijani diaspora organisations issued their own statement expressing their “profound concern” over the planned metallurgical plant in Yeraskh, citing many similar concerns raised in the statement from the Azerbaijani Ministry of Ecology and Natural Resources.

After a week of low-level fighting between Armenia and Azerbaijan, two workers are injured at the plant on Wednesday

As all of this to-and-fro over the Yeraskh metallurgical plant was going on, low-level fighting between Armenia and Azerbaijan continued for days with both sides accusing the other of staging provocations and disseminating disinformation.

Then, at 11.30am on Wednesday (14 June), the Azerbaijani Ministry of Defense issued a statement accusing Armenian armed forces stationed in the direction of Yeraskh of opening fire on Azerbaijani positions stationed in the direction of Heydarabad, in Azerbaijan's Nakhchivan region. The statement added that the Azerbaijani Army took “retaliatory measures”.

The Armenian Defence Ministry, however, released a statement just after midday calling Azerbaijan’s accusation “disinformation”, before accusing Azerbaijan of having opened fire on the Yeraskh metallurgical plant at 11.45am, wounding two people. Armenian authorities have named the wounded as Muhammad Asif and Mirhasan Sahajan, Indian citizens working on the construction of the plant.

Shortly after the shooting, the Armenian Deputy Foreign Minister Vahan Kostanyan announced on Twitter that members of the European Union civilian mission in Armenia visited the construction zone of the metallurgical plant in Yeraskh. Toivo Klaar, the EU Special Representative for the South Caucasus and the Crisis in Georgia, released a separate statement on Twitter, saying that the EU is “closely following developments in the region”.

“The shooting in all areas needs to stop,” he said. “It is essential to keep up the positive momentum of successive meetings and achieve results at the negotiating table that will benefit Armenia, Azerbaijan, and the entire region.”

The spokesperson for the U.S State Department also published his own statement on Twitter. “We are deeply concerned that two civilian employees of a U.S.-affiliated company in Armenia sustained injuries from gunfire from the direction of Azerbaijan,” he said. “We reiterate our call for restraint along the borders as the parties work toward a durable and balanced peace,” the statement concluded.

Speaking on Wednesday evening after the shooting, Armenian Foreign Minister Ararat Mirzoyan announced that “representatives of the international diplomatic corps accredited in Armenia” would visit the site on Thursday (15 June), adding that the Armenian government would keep the issue “in the centre of their attention”.

Armenia and Azerbaijan can all be winners if they do cooperate, whether it be on the environment, on trade, or on any other sector

Disputes like the one surrounding the Yeraskh metallurgical plant pose a genuine risk to the realisation of a durable peace between Armenia and Azerbaijan. Indeed, as the Espoo Convention notes, environmental issues do not respect borders and specific cases should be discussed on an international level when multiple state-parties are concerned. Both Armenia and Azerbaijan will undoubtedly benefit from a wider region where environmental protections are properly adhered to. 

In fact, cooperation on the environment is already the subject of discussions at a track II level. On Monday 6 March, Armenian and Azerbaijani experts gathered in Tbilisi to discuss transboundary water cooperation, with one participant commenting that “we all will be losers if we don’t cooperate.” Such initiatives should continue and can be a critical vector of regional confidence building processes.

But in order for Armenia and Azerbaijan to move forward together in an era of peace, there must also be an understanding that one country’s domestic development can also be to the benefit of the other country. Zero-sum calculations of such issues are unhelpful and distract from the fact that Armenia and Azerbaijan can all be winners if they do cooperate, whether it be on the environment, on trade, or on any other sector.

source: Patrick Norén is the Deputy Editor of commonspace.eu.
photo: Radar Armenia
The views expressed in opinion pieces and commentaries do not necessarily reflect the position of commonspace.eu or its partners.

 

Latest

Editor's choice
Monday Commentary
Monday Commentary: PEACE IN OUR TIME?

Monday Commentary: PEACE IN OUR TIME?

Making peace between Armenia and Azerbaijan was never going to be simple, nor easy, nor quick. It is taking time, writes Dennis Sammut in this Monday Commentary. “There is a sense of realism coming from the leaders of the two countries – President Ilham Aliyev of Azerbaijan and prime minister Nikol Pashinyan of Armenia, that frankly, is necessary and welcome”, he writes. At a time when conflicts are raging all over the world – from Ukraine to the Gulf, from Africa to South Asia, the prospect that Armenia and Azerbaijan had finally, after decades of conflict that left thousands of dead and many more displaced, decided on embarking on a journey of peace was welcomed. Peace between Armenia and Azerbaijan can be top-down up to a point. Both leaders have spent political capital preparing for a peace deal. But both are aware that their people are not ready for peace yet. In fact, in Armenia, most of the elite are negative toward a peace deal with Azerbaijan. Pashinyan needs time to persuade his countryfolk. That is why 2031 is realistic. Ilham Aliyev runs a tighter shop, but he is also not immune to public opinion. Every time someone hits a landmine in Karabakh, which unfortunately happens often, peace comes into question. Which is why Aliyev chooses to sound hardline, more often than not. In pursuing the peace agenda, both Aliyev and Pashinyan need to proceed cautiously. But they are right in making peace the central issue in their agenda. It is the main issue, and the one that will define them in history. So forward, cautiously but resolutely! In pursuing the peace agenda, Aliyev and Pashinyan need to be supported clearly and unambiguously. There are too many people in Baku and Yerevan who are sitting on the sides, waiting. The international community is not doing enough. It is time to be counted. Otherwise, the spoilers will win, and the region will go back to its bad habits. (Click the image to read the full commentary).

Popular

Editor's choice
Monday Commentary
Monday Commentary: European-Azerbaijan relations need an intensive and multifaceted dialogue that is frank and honest

Monday Commentary: European-Azerbaijan relations need an intensive and multifaceted dialogue that is frank and honest

Last week I visited Baku, Azerbaijan. My visit was relatively short, but very intensive, and had many meetings with stakeholders and colleagues. When I arrived in Baku first time in 1996,  Azerbaijan was a different country: weak, poor, and shaken by defeat in war. For thirty year the Karabakh issue dominated the agenda: the political agenda but also the popular mindset. Now, thirty years later, Azerbaijan has returned to Karabakh, and peace with Armenia is on the horizon. It is a new era for Armenia-Azerbaijan relations, for the South Caucasus, but also for Europe.  But we cannot be complacent: the Peace agreement has been initialed but not signed; borders remain closed; TRIPP is ambitious but remains an idea; and there are spoilers who want to turn the clock back. We must not allow them, and in this Europe and Azerbaijan must work together. Europe’ vanguard organization is the European Union – it is a free union of 27 member states; it is a strong global economic force, and increasingly a diplomatic and military force too. But it remains “work in progress” and can often appear dysfunctional. It often lacks collective and institutional memory. In its dealings with Azerbaijan the EU has made many mistakes – not least opening the delegation here late – in 2008. It sometimes appears condescending. Some utterances from the European Parliament and from some quarters in some member states are not understandable even for me. They irritate the Azerbaijanis, but serve no other purpose But Azerbaijan has also not handled relations with the EU well. It has failed to respond when the hand of friendship reached out; and it confused irritating actions, sometimes by well-meaning people; sometimes by outright spoilers, with strategic action. In short, EU-Azerbaijan relations have suffered from a lack of proper dialogue. This dialogue must be frank, honest and multi-faceted involving different segments of society on both sides.   Is Azerbaijan Europe? When Azerbaijan applied to join the Council of Europe in the 1990s, there were some who opposed, saying this was not Europe. I was one of the people who argued that Armenia and Azerbaijan may be on the periphery of the continent geographically, but were European in essence. Certainly their elites. During the discussion on 4 September in Baku, my friend Farhad Mammedov, mentioned that Azerbaijan is not interested in joining the EU, and was now close to the Central Asian countries in the 5 plus 1 format. Neither things mean that Azerbaijan is not Europe. There are several European countries that are not in the EU, and do not want to be, for example Norway and Switzerland. Iceland has recently voted to stay out of the EU. The UK was a member and left. Europe is bigger than the EU, and the holding of the European Political Community summit in Baku in 2027 proves that. Despite all the rhetoric, I never heard the president of Azerbaijan  saying that Azerbaijan is not Europe, nor have I heard any European president say it either. Not wanting to join the EU and forging close relations with neighbouring regions does not make Azerbaijan any less European. It is only logical that when Europeans talk to Azerbaijan they talk like family. The conversation is often frank. It must also be honest, and Europeans need always to remember this too. A frank, honest and multi-faceted dialogue A frank, honest and multifaceted dialogue will contribute to relations between Azerbaijan and the rest of Europe: it will avoid misperception, which unfortunately is very common on both sides; it will provide a forum where problems can be discussed and resolved, and it will increase mutual trust, so that together common problems can be addressed. (click image to read the full Monday Commentary)
Editor's choice
Monday Commentary
Monday Commentary: “The barren rocks of Aden” and “These lands of Yemen are so ruthless”

Monday Commentary: “The barren rocks of Aden” and “These lands of Yemen are so ruthless”

There are two early 20th-century tunes that mark foreign attempts to occupy and “pacify” Yemen. The Scottish tune “The barren rocks of Aden” marks the mobilisation of Highland soldiers, enlisted to be deployed to the Yemeni port of Aden, that in 1837 became the last colony to be incorporated into the British Empire. The tune talks of the harshness of the terrain, but is celebratory, It was even played as a farewell tune to Sir William Luce at the parade in Sharjah celebrating his end as “British Viceroy” in the Middle East in 1966. The second tune is an Anatolian lament. As Ilker Sezer reminded us this weekend, in his weekly feature on “Turkiye Today”, it “mourns the tragic fate of Ottoman soldiers dispatched to the harsh, remote deserts of Yemen during the fall of the empire, young men who marched away from their villages and never returned home. Most of their names, and numbers, were never recorded. Yet, their fate left a mark on the Turkish psyche.” Subsequent invaders have discovered that Yemen is a grave that cannot be overcome by the strength of modern technology, and that whilst Yemeni society is splintered and divided, building a reliable alliance with Yemeni factions is difficult. These are the harsh lessons facing Saudi Arabia, as the Kingdom faces its biggest challenge in its modern history. The leadership of the Kingdom now has to respond decisively. At stake is their very credibility. This is likely to be a long and messy conflict. Saudi military objectives need to be focused: to box in the Houthis rather than destroy them. This is likely to include: (a) regaining territory lost on the Red Sea coast; (b) control over Bab el Mandeb Strait; (c) some kind of cordon sanitaire on the Saudi-Yemeni border; and if things go well (d) the capture of Sanaa. All this would not eliminate the Houthi problem, but it will contain it. In the end the Saudis will have to continue managing Yemen with a mixture of carrot and stick. For the moment, the stick is likely, but the carrot cannot be forgotten either. (click the image to read the Monday Commentary in full)