Lone voice or sign of stress in Russia-China relations?

Chinese and Russian Foreign Ministers met on Wednesday, 30 March, in eastern China. They said they are “more determined” to boost trade ties and enhance bilateral cooperation. However, a former advisor of the Chinese Central Bank, the PBOC, said that the “no limits” relationship, declared by Xi Jinping, is “situational” and should be taken with “a grain of salt”.

China is hosting a two-day conference in the eastern province of Anhui on the situation in Afghanistan. On the sidelines of the conference, Foreign Ministers Wang Yi of China and Sergey Lavrov of Russia, met for bilateral talks where they discussed the possibility of more collaboration and what Moscow calls its “special operation” in Ukraine.

Concerning boosting mutual ties, Wang said, “Both sides are more determined to develop bilateral ties, and are more confident in promoting cooperation in various fields.” The two countries signed an agreement at the Beijing Winter Olympics to improve their partnership in a range of issues including artificial intelligence and information security.

Russia’s invasion of Ukraine has created several geopolitical and economic issues for China, forcing Beijing to develop a balancing act between their foreign policy line and their relationship with Russia. Nevertheless, Wang and Lavrov stated that they would speak with a “united voice” in matters relating to foreign affairs. The ministers condemned “the counterproductive nature of the illegal unilateral sanctions imposed on Russia by the United States and its satellites.”

While the foreign ministers expounded on the extensive links between China and Russia, Li Daokui, a former advisor to the PBOC and current professor at Tsinghua University, said that the relationship was totally “situational”. He said that China will most likely continue doing business with Russia to help out Russians through a difficult period, but the “no limit relationship should be taken with a grain of salt”. In a climate where university professors in China are careful not to deviate from the state line, Li’s statements are revealing.

Sources: CommonSpace.eu with Reuters (London), CNBC (New Jersey), and other media agencies.
Picture: Li Daokui at the World Economic Forum (CTGN)

Related articles

Editor's choice
News
Not quite there yet!

Not quite there yet!

The presidents of Ukraine and the United States were both upbeat after their talks on Sunday (28 December), but clearly there is yet no agreement on how to end the war in Ukraine. Donald Trump and Volodymyr Zelensky said progress had been made during Florida talks but the US president admitted the problem of territory remained "unresolved". While both the US and Ukrainian presidents described the talks as "great", Trump said "one or two very thorny issues" remained outstanding - most notably on the issue of land. Addressing reporters at Mar-a-Lago, Zelensky said they had come to an agreement on "90%" of the 20-point peace plan, while Trump said a security guarantee for Ukraine was "close to 95%" done. Zelensky later said US and Ukrainian teams would meet next week for further talks on issues aimed at ending Russia's nearly four-year war in Ukraine. "We had a substantive conversation on all issues and highly value the progress that the Ukrainian and American teams have made over the past weeks," Zelensky said in a statement on the Telegram messaging app. Russia launched a full-scale invasion of Ukraine in February 2022, and Moscow currently controls about 20% of Ukrainian territory. A proposal to turn the Donbas region in eastern Ukraine, which Russia largely controls, into a demilitarised zone remains "unresolved", Trump said. "Some of that land has been taken," he told reporters after the meeting. "Some of that land is maybe up for grabs, but it may be taken over the next period of a number of months." Moscow currently controls about 75% of the Donetsk region, and some 99% of the neighbouring Luhansk. The regions are collectively known as Donbas. Russia wants Ukraine to pull back from the small part of the territory it still controls in Donbas, while Kyiv has insisted the area could become a free economic zone policed by Ukrainian forces. The US president has repeatedly changed his own position on Ukraine's lost territories, and in September stunned observers by suggesting that Ukraine might be able to take it back. He later reversed course. "[That] is a very tough issue," he said. "One that will get resolved." Security guarantees for Ukraine are "95% done", Trump said, without formally committing to logistical support or troop deployment to help protect Ukraine from future attacks. Trump floated the possibility of trilateral talks between the US, Russia, and Ukraine, saying it could happen "at the right time". Immediately after their bilateral talks, Trump and Zelensky held a one hour meeting with European leaders. European Commission president, Ursula von der Leyen, wrote on X "We had a good hour-long conversation with President Trump and Zelensky. Several European leaders were present and discussed future peace talks. Good progress has been made. Europe stands ready to work with its partners to consolidate this."  

Popular